Most wrong answers in Football IQ are scattered: a dozen different names, each tried by a small share of players. But in some games one wrong name takes over. Half the people playing, sometimes three in four, type the same player, and it isn't the right one.
We went through the app's finished Transfer Guess and Career Path games to find the strongest of these mix-ups. They aren't random. Nearly every one is a player who made the same move, joined the same club in the same summer, or simply shares a surname.
How we counted. For each game we looked at every wrong name players typed, and worked out the share of everyone who played that game who tried it at least once. A game counts as solved if the player named the answer before running out of clues. We left out games with too few plays to give a fair figure, and any case where the "wrong" answer was just another spelling of the right player. Website plays aren't stored per player, so these figures come from the app. Every game below is now in the archive, so nothing here spoils today's game.
Same move, different year
André Schürrle, Chelsea to Wolfsburg, £22m: 29 September
This is the biggest mix-up we found. 74% of players tried Kevin De Bruyne, and only 57% solved it.
It's an easy trap. De Bruyne made exactly the same move a year earlier: Wolfsburg signed him from Chelsea on 18 January 2014 for £18m. Schürrle followed on 2 February 2015 for £22m. De Bruyne's 2014–15 season at Wolfsburg (a Bundesliga record of 21 assists, the DFB-Pokal and Germany's Footballer of the Year award) is the one people remember.
Schürrle has a bigger moment of his own. In the 2014 World Cup final he came off the bench and crossed for Mario Götze's winner in the 113th minute. He still got a Premier League winner's medal for 2014–15, having played 14 league games before leaving. He retired in July 2020, aged 29.
De Bruyne caught people out again the very next day. In the 30 September game, Edin Džeko's £27m move from Wolfsburg to Manchester City in January 2011, 64% of players tried De Bruyne, who made that same move in August 2015. Most still got there, with 85% solving it.
Victor Wanyama, Celtic to Southampton, £12.5m: 8 August
70% of players tried Virgil van Dijk. Just under half (49%) solved it, and Fraser Forster was the next most common wrong answer at 19%.
Van Dijk is the obvious Celtic-to-Southampton name. He signed for Southampton on 1 September 2015 for a reported £13m, two years after Wanyama, and the two fees were almost identical. They were Celtic team-mates for less than three weeks: Van Dijk joined from Groningen on 21 June 2013 and Wanyama left for Southampton on 11 July.
Wanyama's move was a record of its own. At the time it made him the most expensive player ever sold by a Scottish club, beating the £9.5m Spartak Moscow paid for Aiden McGeady, and he became the first Kenyan to play in the Premier League. Tottenham bought him for £11m in 2016.
Danny Drinkwater, Leicester City to Chelsea, £35m: 22 August
66% of players tried N'Golo Kanté, and Ben Chilwell was next at 10%. In the end, 76% solved it.
Kanté and Drinkwater both played in Leicester's midfield in the 2015–16 title season, and both went to Chelsea. Kanté went first, on 16 July 2016, for a reported £32m, and won the title again in his first season, the first player since Eric Cantona in 1993 to win back-to-back English titles with two different clubs. He was named PFA Players' Player of the Year and FWA Footballer of the Year.
Drinkwater followed on 1 September 2017, for £35m, more than Chelsea had paid for Kanté. It didn't work out: he made 12 Premier League appearances for Chelsea, then went out on loan to Burnley, Aston Villa, Kasımpaşa and Reading. He left Chelsea in 2022 and retired in October 2023, aged 33.
Joleon Lescott, Everton to Manchester City, £22m: 28 July
Only 29% of players solved this one. 51% tried John Stones, 17% Gareth Barry and 14% Sylvain Distin.
Stones is the modern version of this transfer. He joined City from Everton on 9 August 2016 for £47.5m, at the time the second-highest fee ever paid for a defender, and later played in City's 2022–23 treble. Lescott made the same move seven years earlier, on 25 August 2009, for a fee reported at about £22m. Barry, the third answer, makes sense too: he joined City that same summer.
Lescott is easy to underrate. He won the FA Cup in 2011 and the Premier League in 2011–12 and 2013–14 with City, and scored for England against France at Euro 2012, one of his 26 caps.
Same summer, same deal
James Milner, Aston Villa to Manchester City, £26m: 29 August
Half the players (50%) tried Gareth Barry, 22% Fabian Delph and 15% Stephen Ireland. Only 38% solved it.
Barry had made the same move a year earlier, signing for City from Villa on 2 June 2009 for a reported £12m. Ireland is the cleverest wrong answer of the lot: he was part of the Milner deal itself, going from City to Villa in the exchange.
The two Villa midfielders are linked for another reason. Barry held the record for most Premier League appearances, 653, until Milner passed him on 21 February 2026. Milner had won the PFA Young Player of the Year award at Villa in 2010, then two league titles at City, and he retired on 1 June 2026 after three seasons at Brighton.
Peter Crouch, Portsmouth to Tottenham, £10m: 11 June
50% of players tried Jermain Defoe, 18% Harry Kane and 16% Niko Kranjčar. 58% solved it.
In 2009 Tottenham signed three players from Portsmouth. Defoe came back to Spurs in January for about £15.75m, Crouch followed on 27 July for £10m, and Kranjčar arrived on 1 September for about £2.5m. Two of the three most common wrong answers were the other two Portsmouth signings.
It was a homecoming for Crouch, too. He had signed his first professional contract at Spurs in 1998 but never played for the first team, and they sold him to QPR for £60,000 in 2000. Back at White Hart Lane, he scored the header against Manchester City in May 2010 that set Spurs up for their first-ever place in the Champions League. He went on to break Alan Shearer's record for headed Premier League goals in 2015.
Same name, same position
Mamadou Sangaré, Lens to Brentford, £39m: 4 September
The hardest game in this list: only 27% solved it, and 52% tried Ibrahim Sangaré.
It's not hard to see why. Ibrahim Sangaré is a midfielder with the same surname, but he's an Ivorian, born in 1997, who joined Nottingham Forest from PSV for £30m in September 2023. Mamadou Sangaré is Malian, born in Bamako in 2002. He's a different player from a different country who also happens to play in midfield in England.
Mamadou came through Red Bull Salzburg's system, with loans in Austria and Belgium, then played for Rapid Wien and Lens. Brentford signed him on 1 August 2026 for a club-record fee, reported at around £39m, on a five-year contract. He had just helped Lens finish second in Ligue 1 and win the Coupe de France.
Same country, same club, same next step
Ramires, Career Path: 14 October
This career was Joinville, Cruzeiro, Benfica, Chelsea, Jiangsu Suning and Palmeiras. 52% of players tried Oscar, 15% David Luiz and 8% Ángel Di María, and only 42% solved it.
Oscar fits the clues that matter most. He's a Brazilian midfielder who joined Chelsea in 2012, and he then moved to the Chinese Super League, signing for Shanghai SIPG in January 2017 for a reported £60m, an Asian record. Ramires had made the same jump a year earlier, joining Jiangsu Suning for a reported £25m in January 2016.
Chelsea fans remember Ramires for one goal: the lob over Víctor Valdés at Camp Nou in the 2012 Champions League semi-final that put Chelsea ahead on away goals on the way to winning the trophy. He also won the Premier League, FA Cup, League Cup and Europa League at Chelsea, and the Copa Libertadores with Palmeiras in 2020.
What the mix-ups tell us
- A route remembers its most famous player. Chelsea to Wolfsburg means De Bruyne, Celtic to Southampton means Van Dijk, and Everton to City means Stones. The right answer was usually the less famous player who made the same move earlier or later.
- Check the year. In almost every game here, the year alone separated the answer from the wrong guess: Schürrle in 2015, not 2014; Lescott in 2009, not 2016; Milner in 2010, not 2009.
- Clubs buy in batches. Spurs took three players from Portsmouth in 2009, City took two Villa midfielders in back-to-back summers, and Chelsea took two of Leicester's title-winning midfield. When a club has been to the same shop twice, think about both players.
Think you'd have spotted the difference? Try today's Transfer Guess or Career Path, and check the year before you answer.
Sources
- Wrong answers and solve rates: Football IQ app game results for the games named above, dated 11 June to 14 October 2026.
- Player careers, fees and honours: Wikipedia articles on André Schürrle, Kevin De Bruyne, Edin Džeko, Victor Wanyama, Virgil van Dijk, Danny Drinkwater, N'Golo Kanté, Joleon Lescott, John Stones, James Milner, Gareth Barry, Peter Crouch, Jermain Defoe, Niko Kranjčar, Mamadou Sangaré, Ibrahim Sangaré, Ramires and Oscar, checked 13 November 2026.
- Brentford sign Mamadou Sangaré from Lens for club-record fee, ESPN, 1 August 2026.