Everyone remembers who scored. Fewer people remember who played right-back. In Starting XI, you see a famous team's line-up on a pitch with five players hidden, and you have to name the missing men.
We went through the Starting XI games finished in the Football IQ app this year to find the players fans forget, even from the biggest nights in football. Some are cult heroes, one is a Champions League final scorer, and two later managed Real Madrid.
How we counted. A hidden player counts as found if the player named him before finishing the game. We left out games with too few plays to give a fair figure, and two league games that weren't famous matches. Website plays aren't stored per player, so these figures come from the app. Every game mentioned here is now in the archive, so nothing spoils a game you can still play today.
Porto, 2004 Champions League final: the team nobody remembers
Our game on 9 October hid five of José Mourinho's Porto side that beat Monaco 3–0 in Gelsenkirchen on 26 May 2004. It was the hardest Starting XI game in our data. The best-known hidden player, Ricardo Carvalho, was found by only 26% of players, and Maniche by 15%.
Paulo Ferreira: found by 6% of players
Ferreira joined Porto from Vitória Setúbal in 2002, and Mourinho turned him from a right midfielder into a right-back. He followed Mourinho to Chelsea on 22 June 2004 for €20 million and won three Premier League titles there.
Most fans know Ferreira as a Chelsea player, which helps explain why so few placed him at Porto. Eight years later he was on the bench for Chelsea in the 2012 Champions League final, an unused substitute.
Carlos Alberto: found by 6% of players
This is the striking one, because Carlos Alberto scored. He opened the scoring in the 39th minute, before Deco and Dmitri Alenichev added the second and third. He was 19, had joined from Fluminense only that January, and came off on the hour.
He never stayed anywhere long enough to be remembered. He went back to Brazil with Corinthians in 2005, joined Werder Bremen in 2007, and spent most of the rest of his career on loans and short deals in Brazil.
Costinha: found by 9% of players
Costinha sat in front of the defence. He had already done his most famous work that season: on 9 March 2004 he scored the goal that knocked Manchester United out in the round of 16. In the final he beat Monaco, his former club.
He won 53 caps for Portugal and reached the Euro 2004 final. A year after Gelsenkirchen he and Maniche were both sold to Dynamo Moscow. Deco was named man of the match, and Mourinho left for Chelsea a week later, which is how most people remember that summer.
Spain, Euro 2012 final: the best team, half forgotten
Spain beat Italy 4–0 in Kyiv on 1 July 2012, the biggest winning margin in a European Championship final. They became the first team to retain the Euros and the first to win three major tournaments in a row. In our game on 15 September, none of the five hidden players was found by more than 21% of players.
Álvaro Arbeloa: found by 12% of players
Arbeloa only started because Carles Puyol was missing the tournament. He won 56 caps for Spain without scoring, and at the 2010 World Cup he played 14 minutes, against Honduras.
His story didn't end there. On 12 January 2026, Real Madrid made him head coach of the first team, in place of the man next to him in this list.
Xabi Alonso: found by 12% of players
This one is the biggest surprise. Alonso had scored both of Spain's goals in the 2–0 quarter-final win over France, on his 100th appearance for his country. He had already won the Champions League with Liverpool, and he went on to manage Bayer Leverkusen to an unbeaten Bundesliga title in 2023–24 and then Real Madrid. It is hard to think of a more famous footballer to forget.
Cesc Fàbregas, the false nine: found by 18% of players
Our game puts Fàbregas up front, which is where Vicente del Bosque played him, with no recognised striker in the side. He crossed for David Silva's opening goal. A midfielder playing up front is hard to place on a pitch.
Sergio Busquets and Gerard Piqué were both found by 21%. Compare that with the 2010 World Cup final, our game on 14 July, where Busquets was found by 74%. Same player, same role, two years apart. The 2010 final is the one fans remember, so its line-up comes back more easily.
Milan, 2003 Champions League final: the old man and the terrier
Milan beat Juventus 3–2 on penalties after a 0–0 draw at Old Trafford on 28 May 2003, the first final between two Italian clubs. Andriy Shevchenko scored the winning penalty, and even he was found by only 53% of players in our game on 7 October.
Alessandro Costacurta: found by 18% of players
Costacurta played right-back that night, aged 37, alongside Alessandro Nesta and Paolo Maldini. He was booked in the 18th minute and replaced by Roque Júnior after 66.
He retired at Milan in 2007, having won five European Cups with the club. He missed both the 1994 Champions League final and the 1994 World Cup final through suspension. On 19 May 2007, aged 41, he scored in Serie A and became the league's oldest goalscorer at the time. Next to Maldini and Nesta, he is the defender fans leave out.
Gennaro Gattuso: found by 24% of players
Gattuso played on the right of midfield, with Andrea Pirlo in the middle and Clarence Seedorf on the left. Seedorf, whose penalty Gianluigi Buffon saved in the shoot-out, was found by 35%.
Gattuso won the Champions League again in 2007 and the World Cup with Italy in 2006, and made 468 appearances for Milan. He later managed Italy, appointed in June 2025. A player that famous at 24% shows how hard it is to place a midfielder in the right final.
England, 1966 World Cup final: the youngest man on the pitch
Alan Ball: found by 31% of players
England beat West Germany 4–2 after extra time at Wembley on 30 July 1966. Geoff Hurst's hat-trick is the story everyone knows. Ball, England's No. 7 in our game on 8 June, was the youngest member of the squad at 21.
He made two of England's goals. His corner led to Martin Peters' goal, and in extra time it was Ball's cross that Hurst turned and shot onto the crossbar for the goal that is still argued about. Weeks later Everton signed him from Blackpool for £112,000, at the time a record fee paid by an English club. Even Gordon Banks was found by only 50% of players in this game.
Chelsea, 2012 Champions League final: the stand-ins
Chelsea beat Bayern Munich 4–3 on penalties in Munich on 19 May 2012 after a 1–1 draw. John Terry was suspended after being sent off in the semi-final, and so were Branislav Ivanović, Raul Meireles and Ramires. In our game on 20 September, Ashley Cole and Frank Lampard were found by 92% of players. The three below were not.
José Bosingwa: found by 41% of players
With Ivanović banned, Bosingwa played the full 120 minutes at right-back. He had been in Porto's 2003–04 squad, and he and Paulo Ferreira were the only two players in this final with experience of a squad that had won a Champions League final.
Juan Mata: found by 44% of players
Mata took the corner, Chelsea's first of the match, that Didier Drogba headed in for the 88th-minute equaliser. He also had the first penalty of the shoot-out saved by Manuel Neuer.
Ryan Bertrand: found by 46% of players
Bertrand, a left-back, started on the left wing. It was his Champions League debut, which made him the first player of the Champions League era to make his debut in the competition in the final. He went on to win 19 England caps.
The ones everyone remembers
For balance, the hidden players almost everyone found:
- Karim Benzema, Real Madrid, 2017 Champions League final (18 September): 94%. Real beat Juventus 4–1 in Cardiff. Benzema didn't score; Cristiano Ronaldo got two.
- Ángel Di María, Argentina, 2022 World Cup final (17 September): 93%. He won the penalty for Lionel Messi's opener and scored the second himself.
- Ashley Cole and Frank Lampard, Chelsea, 2012 (20 September): 92% each.
What the forgotten men have in common
- The goal doesn't save you. Carlos Alberto scored in a Champions League final and was found by 6%. Ball made two goals in a World Cup final and was found by 31%.
- Fans remember players at their famous club. Ferreira is a Chelsea player in most memories, and Costinha and Maniche left Porto a year later. A team that broke up quickly is a team people forget.
- The second final fades. Spain's 2010 line-up came back easily; the side that won more convincingly in 2012 did not.
Think you'd do better? Play today's Starting XI and see how many of the hidden men you can name.
Sources
- Found rates: Football IQ app results for Starting XI games dated up to 10 November 2026, counted in November 2026.
- Matches and line-ups: Wikipedia articles on the 2004 UEFA Champions League final, UEFA Euro 2012 final, 2010 FIFA World Cup final, 2003 UEFA Champions League final, 1966 FIFA World Cup final, 2012 UEFA Champions League final, 2017 UEFA Champions League final and 2022 FIFA World Cup final, checked 13 November 2026.
- Player careers: Wikipedia articles on Paulo Ferreira, Carlos Alberto, Costinha, Maniche, Álvaro Arbeloa, Xabi Alonso, Alessandro Costacurta, Gennaro Gattuso, Alan Ball, José Bosingwa and Ryan Bertrand, checked 13 November 2026.
- Xabi Alonso leaves Real Madrid as Álvaro Arbeloa takes charge, Sky Sports, 12 January 2026.