In Top Tens, you get a football list, such as the clubs with the most league titles or the players who won the Ballon d'Or more than once, and try to name all ten entries. Most people get the famous names at the top. The interesting part is the names at the bottom that almost nobody gets.

We went through every Top Tens game finished in the Football IQ app this year and looked at each answer on its own, to see what share of players found it. Some answers were found by nearly everyone. A few were found by no one at all, and one list had eight of them.

How we counted. An answer counts as found if the player typed it before finishing the game or giving up. Answers shown after giving up don't count. We left out games with too few plays to give a fair figure. Website plays aren't stored per player, so these figures come from the app. Each list is as it stood on the day of the game, and every game below is now in the archive, so nothing here spoils a game you can still play for free today.

Most Premier League appearances without scoring: 21 April

This was the hardest list of the year. Eight of its ten answers were found by nobody (0%). The top two were barely better: Kenny Cunningham was found by 5% of players and Tony Hibbert by 2%.

  • Kenny Cunningham, 335 games: 5%
  • Tony Hibbert, 265: 2%
  • Des Walker, 264: 0%
  • Richard Shaw, 253: 0%
  • Stéphane Henchoz, 243: 0%
  • Danny Simpson, 213: 0%
  • Steve Potts, 204: 0%
  • Lucas Radebe, 197: 0%
  • Alan Kimble, 181: 0%
  • Justin Edinburgh, 174: 0%

The list leaves out goalkeepers, so every answer is a defender, and most of them played their Premier League football in the 1990s and early 2000s. Most Top Tens lists have one huge name at the top to start you off. This one has none, because the whole point of the list is that these players were never in the goals.

Kenny Cunningham and Tony Hibbert

Cunningham played 335 Premier League games for Wimbledon and Birmingham City without scoring, 70 more than anyone else on the list. The Dublin-born defender won 72 caps for the Republic of Ireland, went to the 2002 World Cup and captained Ireland afterwards. His only league goal came for Millwall, before he joined Wimbledon in 1994.

Hibbert spent his whole career at Everton: 328 competitive games, 265 of them in the Premier League, and not one goal. At the 2009 FA Cup semi-final, Everton fans held up a banner reading "If Hibbert Scores, We Riot". When he finally scored, with a free kick in his testimonial against AEK Athens on 8 August 2012, fans ran onto the pitch.

Des Walker

All 264 of Walker's Premier League games came for Sheffield Wednesday. He played 801 club games in all and scored once, an equaliser for Nottingham Forest in a 1–1 draw with Luton Town on 1 January 1992, months before the Premier League began. He won 59 England caps and started all seven of England's games at the 1990 World Cup.

The rest of the list

  • Richard Shaw played 74 Premier League games for Crystal Palace and 179 for Coventry City. His first Coventry goal came in May 2004, against Gillingham, in the second tier.
  • Stéphane Henchoz won 72 caps for Switzerland and partnered Sami Hyypiä in the Liverpool side that won the FA Cup, League Cup and UEFA Cup in 2001. His four league goals all came in Switzerland and Germany.
  • Danny Simpson is the most recent name here and the hardest miss: he played 30 league games when Leicester City won the Premier League in 2015–16.
  • Steve Potts, born in Hartford, Connecticut, captained West Ham from 1993 to 1996. His one goal for the club, in a 7–1 win over Hull City in 1990, came before the Premier League.
  • Lucas Radebe joined Leeds from Kaizer Chiefs for £250,000 in 1994 and became club captain. He captained South Africa at the 1998 and 2002 World Cups, and the band Kaiser Chiefs took their name from his old club.
  • Alan Kimble scored 24 goals for Cambridge United, mostly penalties, but only once for Wimbledon, in the League Cup against Huddersfield Town.
  • Justin Edinburgh won the FA Cup with Tottenham in 1991 and the League Cup in 1999. He died in June 2019, aged 49, weeks after leading Leyton Orient back into the Football League as manager.

Men's Ballon d'Or multiple winners through 2025: 10 September

The top of this list was easy: Lionel Messi (eight wins) and Cristiano Ronaldo (five) were both found by 97% of players, and the Brazilian Ronaldo (two) by 81%. The three-time winners were next: Michel Platini 69%, Johan Cruyff 62% and Marco van Basten 59%.

The trouble came with the other two-time winners. Kevin Keegan was found by 47%, Franz Beckenbauer by 38%, Alfredo Di Stéfano by 34% and Karl-Heinz Rummenigge by only 19%.

These four won their awards between 1957 and 1981, and younger fans tend to know them for other things: Keegan as a manager, Beckenbauer as a World Cup-winning captain and coach, Rummenigge as Bayern's long-serving chief executive. It also helps to be English: Keegan was found by more players than Beckenbauer or Di Stéfano.

Karl-Heinz Rummenigge: found by 19%

Rummenigge won the Ballon d'Or in 1980 and 1981. He scored 162 league goals in 310 games for Bayern Munich, won the European Cup with them in 1975 and 1976, won Euro 1980 with West Germany, and captained his country in the 1982 and 1986 World Cup finals, losing both. From 2002 to 2021 he ran Bayern as chairman of the executive board.

Alfredo Di Stéfano: found by 34%

Di Stéfano won in 1957 and 1959. Real Madrid won the first five European Cups, from 1956 to 1960, and he scored in each of those finals. He played for Argentina and later for Spain, but never played a World Cup match. In 1989 he was given the Super Ballon d'Or for the best player of the previous three decades, and he is still its only winner.

Franz Beckenbauer and Kevin Keegan

Beckenbauer won in 1972 and 1976. He captained Bayern to three European Cups in a row from 1974 to 1976 and captained West Germany to the 1974 World Cup, then managed them to the 1990 title. Keegan won in 1978 and 1979 at Hamburg, who had paid Liverpool £500,000 for him in 1977. He won the Bundesliga there in 1978–79.

Clubs with the most English top-flight titles: 24 May

Almost everyone found the modern giants. Arsenal (14 titles) were found by 97% of players, and Liverpool (20), Manchester United (20), Manchester City (10) and Chelsea (6) by 94% each. Aston Villa (7) were found by 86% and Everton (9) by 77%.

Further down, Newcastle United (4) were found by 69% and Sunderland (6) by 63%. Sheffield Wednesday (4) were found by only 23%, the one answer on the list that fewer than a quarter of players named.

The reason is the dates. Newcastle's last title came in 1927, Wednesday's in 1930 and Sunderland's in 1936.

Sheffield Wednesday: found by 23%

Wednesday won back-to-back titles twice, in 1902–03 and 1903–04, and again in 1928–29 and 1929–30. The first two came as The Wednesday: the club didn't add Sheffield to its name until 1929. Their four titles put them level with Newcastle and one ahead of Blackburn Rovers, Huddersfield Town, Wolves and Leeds United.

Sunderland and Newcastle

Sunderland's six titles all came between 1891–92 and 1935–36, which puts them level with Chelsea. Newcastle's four came between 1904–05 and 1926–27.

What the lists tell us

  1. Players remember goals, not games. On a list made up only of defenders who never scored, almost nobody found anyone.
  2. Fame in another job hides you. Rummenigge spent nearly 20 years running Bayern and Beckenbauer won a World Cup as a coach, and most of our players missed them as Ballon d'Or winners.
  3. Old success fades. Sunderland, Newcastle and Sheffield Wednesday haven't won the league for 90 years or more, and they were the three clubs players forgot.

Want to see which names you'd miss? Play today's Top Tens before it reaches the archive.

Sources